Football All-Time Scores
| 1998 | 1999 | 2000 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) |
| Record: 2-8 MSFA MEL 7th place 1-5 | Record: 8-3 MSFA MEL Champs 6-0 | Record: 10-2 MSFA MEL Champs 6-0 |
| W 56 @ St. Xavier 28 | L 6 @ Valparaiso 35 | W 56 @ Butler 37 |
| L 18 Taylor 40 | W 42 Saint Xavier 38 | W 84 Iowa Wesleyan 9 |
| L 24 @ Olivet Nazarene 28 | L 21 McKendree 27 | W 34 Valparaiso 30 |
| L 30 +Malone 55 | W 56 +Geneva 26 | L 14 @ McKendree 28 |
| L 27 +@ Tri-State 71 | W 21 +@ Tiffin 14 | W 21 +@ Geneva 20 |
| L 41 +Walsh (2 OT) 44 | W 35 +Urbana 12 | W 42 +Tiffin 13 |
| L 34 +@ Geneva 45 | W 54 Trinity 36 | W 44 +@ Urbana 14 |
| L 15 +Tiffin 21 | W 30 +@ Malone 14 | W 48 +Malone 10 |
| W 61 +@ Urbana 26 | W 61 +Tri-State 14 | W 21 +@ Tri-State 14 |
| L 35 Iowa Wesleyan 41 | W 40 +@ Walsh 23 | W 42 +Walsh 14 |
| L 0 *@ Georgetown 38 | W 48 *Lambuth 33 | |
| L 19 **@ Georgetown 37 | ||
| 2001 | 2002 | 2003 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) |
| Record: 9-2 MSFA MEL Tri-Champs 5-1 | Record: 11-1 MSFA MEL Champs 6-0 | Record: 12-1 MSFA MEL Champs 6-0 |
| W 41 Butler 20 | W 41 @ Tiffin 31 | W 48 Tiffin 31 |
| W 49 @ Iowa Wesleyan 9 | W 45 Iowa Wesleyan 20 | W 49 @ William Penn 14 |
| W 20 Wis.-LaCrosse 12 | W 49 @ William Penn 14 | W 45 St. Ambrose 40 |
| W 23 McKendree 15 | W 35 +@ Geneva 28 | W 49 +Geneva 16 |
| W 30 +Geneva 6 | W 77 Quincy 21 | W 47 @ Butler 16 |
| W 20 +@ Tiffin 14 | W 70 +Urbana 0 | W 38 +@ Urbana 23 |
| W 42 +Urbana 38 | W 35 +@ Taylor 20 | W 48 +Taylor 14 |
| W 58 +@ Malone 17 | W 33 +Malone 27 | W 36 +@ Malone 14 |
| L 20 +Tri-State 27 | W 48 +@ Tri-State 28 | W 34 +Quincy 13 |
| W 30 +@ Walsh 12 | W 40 +Walsh 29 | W 41 +@ Walsh 24 |
| L 21 @ *Campbellsville 42 | W 34 * St. Xavier 30 | W 34 *Georgetown 23 |
| L 0 @ ** Georgetown 24 | W 41 **St. Ambrose (IL) 14 | |
| L 14 ***@ Carroll (MT) 38 | ||
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY, NAIA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) |
| Record: 13-1, MSFA MEL Champs 7-0 | Record: 13-1, MSFA MEL Champs 7-0 | Record: 13-1, MSFA MEL Champs 6-0 |
| W 55 +Ohio Dominican 3 | W 42 @ Indiana State 10 | W 39 @ William Penn 6 |
| W 33 @ McKendree 10 | W 28 McKendree 21 | W 63 Pikeville 0 |
| W 62 Iowa Wesleyan 8 | W 35 UW-Eau Claire 10 | W 63 UW-River Falls 8 |
| W 30 @ Geneva 24 | W 50 #19 Geneva 22 | W 21 #27 Ohio Dominican 17 |
| W 35 Butler7 | W 49 @ Ohio Dominican 7 | W 35 #18 Urbana 12 |
| W 37 Urbana 20 | W 35 @ #19 Urbana 3 | W 49 @ Taylor 0 |
| W 46 @ Taylor 0 | W 55 Taylor 0 | W 34 #23 Malone 12 |
| W 40 Malone 6 | W 28 @ Malone 7 | W 55 @ Seton Hill (PA) 0 |
| W 49 @ Quincy 13 | W 53 Quincy 19 | W 21 #3 Walsh 7 |
| W 42 Walsh 14 | W 21 @ #11 Walsh 7 | W 21 @ Geneva 20 |
| W 53 *Morningside 3 | W 41 *#13 Pikeville (Ky) 7 | W 42 * #16 Walsh 3 |
| W 48 **Hastings 17 | W 44 **#5 Georgetown 14 | W 42 ** #8 Bethel (TN) 35 |
| W 12 ***Georgetown 7 | W 42 ***# 3 Morningside 14 | W 49 ***#9 Saint Xavier (IL) 0 |
| NAIA Championship | NAIA Championship | NAIA Championship |
| L 13 Carroll 5 | L 10 #1 Carroll 27 | L 19 #2 Sioux Falls (SD) 23 |
| 2007 | 2008 | 2009 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley |
| Record: 11-2, MSFA MEL 6-1 | Record: 12-1, MSFA MEL 6-0 | Record: 7-3, MSFA MEL 5-2 |
| W 71 William Penn (IA) 7 | W 67 Trinity International 0 | W 55 Iowa Wesleyan 0 |
| W 55 @ Pikeville (KY) 3 | W 21 @ Quincy 0 | W 30 @ #9 St. Ambrose 10 |
| W 20 @ #15 St. Ambrose (IA) 7 | W 55 @ Taylor 7 | W 28 Marian 7 |
| L 20 @ #6 Ohio Dominican 30 | W 43 #10 St. Ambrose 14 | W 42 @ #23 Malone 14 |
| W 57 Marian (OH) 7 | W 35 #8 Ohio Dominican 0 | W 20 @ #20 Walsh 14 |
| W 69 Taylor (IN) 29 | W 63 @ Marian 14 | W 63 Trinity International 7 |
| W 42 @ Walsh (OH) 14 | W 52 Walsh 12 | L 37 @ Missouri Science & Tech 39 |
| W 42 #31Urbana (OH) 16 | W 62 @ Urbana 20 | W 56 Olivet Nazarene 7 |
| W 31 @ #18 Malone (OH) 17 | W 45 #10 Malone 24 | L 24 #6 St. Xavier 36 |
| W 42 #6 St. Xavier (IL) 13 | W 47 @ #18 St. Xavier 30 | L 16 @ #25 Taylor 23 |
| W 35 * #12 Lindenwood (MO) 14 | W 58 #11 Union (KY) 3 | |
| W 30 ** @ #4 Bethel (TN) 27 | W 31 #8 U. of Cumberlands (KY) 20 | |
| L 7 ***#2 @ Carroll (MT) 23 | L 7 @ #1 Sioux Falls (SD) 24 | |
| 2010 | 2011 |
2012
|
| Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) |
| Record: 10-2, MSFA MEL 6-1 (2nd) | Record: 9-3, MSFA MEL 5-2 (2nd) |
Record: 9-3, MSFA MEL 4-1 (T-1st)
|
| W 70 @ Iowa Wesleyan 7 | W 34 @ St. Ambrose 33 |
W 46 @ Texas College 10
|
| W 31 #17 St. Ambrose 20 | W 33 McKendree 7 |
W 39 UWSP 31
|
| W 28 @ #13 Marian 25 | W 69 @ Concordia 0 |
L 14 #20 St. Ambrose 15
|
| W 23 Malone 17 | L 31 #1 St. Xavier 42 |
W 76 Concordia 14
|
| W 20 #8 Walsh 14 | W 42 at Walsh (2 OT) 41 |
W 25 @ #1 St. Xavier 13
|
| W 33 @ Trinity International 6 | L 13 #2 Marian 40 |
L 38 @ #1 Marian 45
|
| W 41 Missouri Science & Tech 14 | W 47 Malone 10 |
W 28 @ #5 William Penn 19
|
| W 63 @ Olivet Nazarene 7 | W 34 @ Quincy 7 |
W 31 Siena Heights 7
|
| L 6 @ #3 St. Xavier 30 | W 46 @ Taylor 14 |
W 21 Taylor 0
|
| W 33 Taylor 21 | W 59 Central State 20 |
W 44 @ Lindenwood-Belleville 7
|
| W 46 *@ #5 Lindenwood (MO) 38 | W 28 *@ #7 Missouri Valley 14 |
W 22 * #11 Baker (Kan.) 17
|
| L 21 **@ #3 St. Xavier (IL) 40 | L 14 **@ #3 Georgetown (KY) 26 |
L 34 **@ #5 Marian 45
|
| 2013 | 2014 | 2015 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley (MSFA COY) |
| Record: 9-3, MSFA MEL 5-1 (1st) | Record: 6-5, MSFA MEL 4-2 (3rd) | Record: 11-1, MSFA MEL 6-0 (1st) |
| W 31 @ #16 William Penn 13 | W 42 Missouri Baptist 10 | W 50 Olivet Nazarene 16 |
| W 38 #7 St. Ambrose 37 | L 27 William Penn 28 | W 48 @ Taylor 42 |
| L 7 @ #7 Grand View 23 | W 27 @ #25 St. Ambrose 13 | W 45 Trinity International 3 |
| W 28 @ #25 Siena Heights | L 9 #8 Grand View 21 | W 74 @ Lindenwood-Belleville 13 |
| W 45 #10 St. Xavier 20 | L 21 Siena Heights 27 | W 45 @ #6 Marian 42 |
| W 37 @ #20 USF-IL 28 | L 26 #16 St. Xavier 53 | W 49 Siena Heights 25 |
| L 24 Robert Morris 28 | W 42 #18 USF-IL 20 | W 48 Concordia 7 |
| W 54 Concordia (MI) 0 | W 38 @ #12 Robert Morris 20 | W 38 @ #9 Robert Morris 29 |
| W 20 @ Taylor 12 | W 30 @ Concordia 14 | W 64 @ Missouri Baptist 6 |
| W 41 #27 Marian 24 | W 42 Taylor 0 | W 37 *#12 Reinhardt 26 |
| W 20 *#9 Faulkner (AL) 13 | L 18 #9 Marian 51 | W 42 **#5 Montana Tech 20 |
| L 14 **@ #1 Cumberlands (KY) 28 | L 14 ***#6 Marian 45 | |
| 2016 | 2017 | 2018 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley (NAIA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley (NAIA COY) | Coach: Kevin Donley |
| Record: 13-1, MSFA MEL 5-1 (2nd) | Record: 14-0, MSFA MEL 6-0 (1st) | Record: 10-3, MSFA MEL 4-2 (3rd) |
| W 34 @ Trinity International 20 | W 55 @ Jamestown 7 | W 42 Robert Morris 9 |
| W 58 @ Olivet Nazarene 14 | W 68 USF-IL 23 | W 49 @ USF-IL 19 |
| W 37 Taylor 6 | W 49 @ #23 St. Ambrose 21 | W 60 St. Ambrose 14 |
| W 63 Lindenwood-Belleville 7 | W 48 #11 St. Xavier 23 | W 27 @ #20 St. Xavier 19 |
| L 21 #1 Marian 35 | W 31 @ #8 Marian 24 | L 28 #6 Marian 37 |
| W 24 @ Siena Heights 22 | W 35 #20 Concordia 18 | L 3 @ #14 Concordia 7 |
| W 44 @ Concordia 6 | W 36 @ Siena Heights 9 | W 22 #20 Siena Heights 19 (OT) |
| W 28 #24 Robert Morris 21 | W 56 @ Missouri Baptist 23 | W 51 Missouri Baptist 7 |
| W 56 Missouri Baptist 24 | W 70 Lindenwood-Belleville 0 | W 64 @ Lindenwood-Belleville 25 |
| W 35 @ Davenport 6 | W 40 Taylor 20 | W 40 @ Taylor 20 |
| W 79 *#11 Missouri Valley 20 | W 26 *#15 Benedictine 21 | W 34 *#10 Grand View 3 |
| W 42 **#5 Morningside 35 | W 30 **#10 Northwestern 3 | W 33 **#12 Baker 23 |
| W 42 ***@ #3 Reinhardt 24 | W 43 ***#3 Morningside 36 | L 28 ***@ Morningside 34 (OT) |
| NAIA Championship | NAIA Championship | |
| W 38 #2 Baker 17 Championship | W 24 #2 Reinhardt 13 Championship | |
| 2019 | 2020 (COVID-shortened season) | 2021 |
| Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley | Coach: Kevin Donley |
| Record: 7-3, MSFA MEL 4-2 (t-2nd) | Record: 2-2; MSFA 2-2 | Record: |
| W 56 @ USF-IL 6 | W 24 Taylor 10 | |
| W 29 @ Robert Morris 16 | L 24 @ #13 Concordia 21 | |
| W 31 St. Ambrose 13 | W 17 @ IWU 13 | |
| L 10 @ Marian 28 | L 41 #10 Marian 34 | |
| W 34 Concordia 27 | ||
| W 31 Indiana Wesleyan 30 | ||
| L 14 Siena Heights 24 | ||
| W 59 @ Lawrence Tech 20 | ||
| W 27 @ Taylor 14 | ||
| L 26 *@ Lindsey Wilson 30 | ||